DA drops charges against man accused of throwing kittens to their death on I-65 in Homewood

Charges have officially been dropped against Thomas Ronald Liccione, the 21-year-old man who previously faced an aggravated animal cruelty charge following allegations of throwing kittens from a moving vehicle on Interstate 65 in Homewood.

Liccione was initially arrested on May 31 after reports surfaced regarding the incident near Lakeshore Parkway. However, the Jefferson County District Attorney’s Office filed a motion this past Friday to dismiss the case, stating that there was no longer sufficient probable cause to believe Liccione committed the offense. Jefferson County District Judge William Bell granted the motion, clearing the way for the dismissal.

The Investigation and Dismissal

The case began on May 30 when Homewood police received multiple 911 calls regarding kittens being thrown from a vehicle. One caller followed the suspect car while providing details, including a tag number and vehicle description. When officers caught up to the vehicle, Liccione was the sole occupant.

Following the initial arrest, a Homewood police investigator conducted a thorough follow-up, which included reviewing 911 audio, examining body camera footage, searching for relevant video, re-interviewing witnesses, and analyzing data from Liccione’s cell phone. Deputy District Attorney Shawn Allen confirmed that after this extensive review, prosecutors and the investigator reached a consensus: the evidence did not support a finding of probable cause.

Defense Response

Attorney Eli Sargent, representing Liccione, stated that his client has maintained his innocence throughout the ordeal. “While the allegations generated significant public attention, the swift dismissal speaks for itself,” Sargent said. He emphasized that the situation serves as a reminder to the public not to rush to judgment, noting that an arrest is simply an unproven allegation.

“This case is a clear illustration of our justice system functioning as intended,” Sargent added. “We are pleased this is behind us.”

Moving Forward

While the charge against Liccione has been dismissed, Deputy District Attorney Shawn Allen noted that the investigation remains open. If new evidence emerges that identifies the person responsible for the act, the district attorney’s office intends to take appropriate action.