Goodman: DeBoer owes Austin Mack nothing

This is an opinion column.

When Kalen DeBoer stepped into the head coaching role at Alabama, he made a seismic personnel move early on: he parted ways with Julian Sayin, a highly touted freshman quarterback prospect.

It was a gutsy gamble. DeBoer had already identified his signal-caller of the future in Austin Mack, who followed his coach from the Washington program to Tuscaloosa. Now, we are about to discover if hitching his wagon to Mack was a masterstroke or a massive miscalculation.

The Battle for QB1

Alabama opens fall camp this Sunday, with a Sept. 5 kickoff against East Carolina looming. The spotlight is fixed firmly on the competition between Austin Mack and Keelon Russell. While the Crimson Tide's quarterback situation remains shrouded in mystery, Julian Sayin has already been named the starter for preseason No. 1 Ohio State.

Recent rankings from Sports Illustrated offer an interesting perspective on the landscape. The publication ranked 68 projected Power Four starters; Mack didn't even crack the list, while Russell checked in at No. 30. While these rankings are based more on hype than actual performance, the uncertainty surrounding Alabama’s starter feels like uncharted territory for a program accustomed to elite quarterback play.

The Shadow of the Past

The current situation mirrors a forgotten chapter from 1998 under coach Mike DuBose. Fifth-year senior JD Phillips took the reins for the Crimson Tide, but after throwing one touchdown against two interceptions, he was replaced after just four games by Andrew Zow. DeBoer is betting that his history with Mack will yield a different outcome, but the stakes are high—particularly with a challenging road trip to Kentucky in Week 2.

Is there still a place for loyalty in the modern era of college football? From a romantic perspective, it is a virtue worth preserving. From a pragmatic standpoint, however, Alabama should be chasing the best talent the market can provide. We see this shift in programs like Miami, which bypassed three-year veteran Emory Williams to invest millions in transfer portal stars like Carson Beck and Darian Mensah.

The Bottom Line

Mack has shown incredible patience, having not started a game in four years since reclassifying from the 2024 to 2023 high school class. He knows DeBoer’s system better than anyone, and he has rightfully earned admiration for sticking with the process through his time as a redshirt at Washington and his tenure backing up Ty Simpson in 2025.

Yet, let’s be clear: DeBoer owes Mack nothing. In the current landscape of the SEC, where players are compensated and expectations are sky-high, loyalty is a dangerous currency. If Mack earns the job and succeeds, this will be a legendary story of perseverance. If he starts and struggles, the accountability will rest squarely on the coaching staff. It goes without Sayin.

Mailbag Sound Off

Have a question for Joe? Want to weigh in on the quarterback competition? Send your thoughts via email to let your voice be heard in the upcoming reader mailbag.