Goodman: Pochettino makes massive mistake with USMNT World Cup roster

Mauricio Pochettino has made a significant call regarding the USMNT World Cup roster, and for those hoping to see an Alabamian shine on the global stage, it is a tough pill to swallow: Tanner Tessmann has been left off the squad.

A Missing Physical Edge

Tessmann, currently playing club soccer for Lyon in France, brings a physical presence that this American squad arguably lacks. While he has been working through a muscle strain, his recent form in friendlies suggested he would be a lock for the 26-man roster announced this past Tuesday. Without his ruggedness in the defensive midfield—often paired with Tyler Adams—there are legitimate concerns about whether this team has the grit required to compete against the world's best.

Questions and Doubts

The U.S. enters the tournament with heavy expectations, and failing to advance out of a group that features Paraguay, Australia, and Türkiye would be an undeniable failure. Group play kicks off on June 13 against Paraguay, followed by the knockout rounds starting June 28.

While the talent pool is often described as a 'golden generation,' the reality on the pitch has frequently felt like false hype. Pochettino is betting big on potential, opting to include Gio Reyna despite questions surrounding his consistency, fitness, and past controversies. Choosing a high-risk talent over the reliable, physical toughness of a player like Tessmann is a gamble that may define Pochettino's tenure.

The Status of Chris Richards

The roster decisions are even more scrutinized given the status of fellow Alabamian Chris Richards. Despite suffering a torn ankle ligament, the 2025 U.S. Men’s Soccer Player of the Year still made the cut. Pochettino has indicated he is still assessing the damage, as rules allow for injury reserves to be added until one day before the team's first match. Richards' leadership is vital, and fans can keep an eye on his status during today's Europa League final as Crystal Palace takes on Rayo Vallecano at 2 p.m. CT.

The Path Forward

With both Alabama natives facing injury questions and Tessmann officially omitted, the margin for error for the USMNT is shrinking. If this team wants to avoid an early exit against the likes of tournament favorites like Spain, France, England, Brazil, and Argentina, they must establish a tone of toughness immediately. Right now, the reasons to doubt are starting to pile up.

Mailbag Sound Off

Got a question for Joe? Want to get something off your chest? Send Joe an email about what’s on your mind. Let your voice be heard. Ask him anything for the reader mailbag.